Today: May 20, 2024
Today: May 20, 2024

Australian regulator says Musk's X should not set limits of internet law

Share This
LA Post: Australian regulator says Musk's X should not set limits of internet law
May 10, 2024
Byron Kaye - Reuters

By Byron Kaye

SYDNEY (Reuters) -Elon Musk's X has policies to take down harmful content when it chooses but should not be allowed to overrule Australian law in deciding what can be viewed there, a lawyer for the cyber regulator told a hearing into video of a bishop being stabbed.

X, formerly Twitter, is fighting an order by the eSafety Commissioner to remove 65 posts showing video of an Assyrian Christian bishop being knifed mid-sermon in Sydney last month, in what authorities called a terrorist attack.

"X says ... global removal is reasonable when X does it, because X wants to do it, but it becomes unreasonable when X is told to do it by the laws of Australia," Tim Begbie, the lawyer, told a hearing of the Federal Court, Australia's second-highest.

Other platforms, such as Meta, took down the content quickly when asked, he said, adding that X had policies to remove very harmful content, as responsible services did.

But X's opposition to global removal could not be right as it would determine the definition of "reasonable" within the terms of Australia's Online Safety Act, he added.

The company Musk bought in 2022, with a declared mission to save free speech, says it has blocked Australia from seeing the posts but refuses to remove them globally on the grounds that one country's rules should not control the internet.

Begbie said the dispute was not a debate about free speech but rather about the practicality of the Australian law that gives the regulator power to protect citizens from the most objectionable content.

Geo-blocking Australians, the solution X offered, was ineffective because a quarter of the population used virtual private networks that disguise their locations, he added.

"Global removal in these circumstances is a reasonable step," he said. "It would achieve what parliament intended, which is no accessibility to end users in Australia."

X's lawyer, Bret Walker, said Australian laws left it open to interpretation what amounted to reasonable steps to protect the country from offensive content but the Musk-owned company had gone to reasonable lengths.

"The idea that it's better for the whole world not to see this obviously newsworthy matter, presumably to form their own views, and to consider the views of others ... is in our submission a startling one," he told the court.

"There should be much more than a ripple of apprehension that this country would take the approach that if this is the only way we can control what's available to end users in Australia, then it's a reasonable step to deny it to everybody on earth."

While the matter has been in court, Federal Court Judge Geoffrey Kennett has issued a temporary takedown order of the posts. On Friday he extended the temporary order to June 10 when he will give a final decision.

(Reporting by Byron Kaye; Editing by Clarence Fernandez and Christian Schmollinger)

Popular

Target to lower prices on about 5,000 basic goods as inflation sends customers scrounging for deals

Target plans on cutting prices on thousands of consumer basics this summer, goods ranging from diapers to milk, with more Americans paying closer attention to their spending as inflation cuts into household budgets

Target to lower prices on about 5,000 basic goods as inflation sends customers scrounging for deals

Red Lobster seeks bankruptcy protection days after closing dozens of restaurants

Red Lobster is filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection shortly after closing some of its restaurants

Red Lobster seeks bankruptcy protection days after closing dozens of restaurants

Jim Otto, 'Mr. Raider' and Pro Football Hall of Famer, dies at 86

Jim Otto, the Hall of Fame center known as Mr. Raider for his durability through a litany of injuries, has died

Jim Otto, 'Mr. Raider' and Pro Football Hall of Famer, dies at 86

US pediatricians group reverses decades-old ban on breastfeeding for those with HIV

A top U.S. pediatricians’ group is making a sharp policy change about breastfeeding by people with HIV

US pediatricians group reverses decades-old ban on breastfeeding for those with HIV

Related

Pentagon vows to keep weapons moving to Ukraine as Kyiv faces a renewed assault by Russia

Pentagon vows to keep weapons moving to Ukraine as Kyiv faces a renewed assault by Russia

Who is Jacob Zuma, the former South African president disqualified from next week's election?

Who is Jacob Zuma, the former South African president disqualified from next week's election?

Storms damage homes in Oklahoma and Kansas. But in Houston, most power is restored

Storms damage homes in Oklahoma and Kansas. But in Houston, most power is restored

ICC prosecutor seeks arrest warrant for Israeli and Hamas leaders, including Netanyahu

ICC prosecutor seeks arrest warrant for Israeli and Hamas leaders, including Netanyahu
- Advertisement -
Advertisement: Limited Time Offer